As the source itself has never been doubted, it is astonishing that Christopher Columbus' notes have not been taken seriously in historiography and why this trip of his is still unknown.Ignoring the fact that there is a genuine text in the handwriting of Columbus describing his stay in Galway (Ireland), some historians even refuse to accept that Columbus went as far as England.
As the source itself has never been doubted, it is astonishing that Christopher Columbus' notes have not been taken seriously in historiography and why this trip of his is still unknown.Ignoring the fact that there is a genuine text in the handwriting of Columbus describing his stay in Galway (Ireland), some historians even refuse to accept that Columbus went as far as England.Tags: Research Paper Topics TechnologySuggested Topics For Research PaperBusiness Plan For A Car WashUses & Misuses Of Internet EssayGood Persuasive Essay About School UniformsHomework HassleThesis Statement Jim Burke
It is now known that in the 15th century the climate was much warmer than in following centuries. According to a contemporary chronicle, the winter of 1477 was extraordinarily mild: even the northern part of Iceland was without any snow until March and the South coast without any ice (sniolans jör). Therefore, Columbus' statement, that the sea wasn’t frozen during the time he was there must be reasonable. Frucuoso writes, that João Vaz Cortereal and Alvaro Martins Homem were sent out by the Portuguese king to discover lands. (in 1448 Icelandic Annals report nine churches and congregations), although many Greenlanders had already emigrated to Canada because of better living conditions there. A., 1962 The Cabot voyages and the Bristol Discovery under Henry VII (Hakluyt Society, 2nd ser. identified this Streicte as Jones Sound or Lancaster Sound because of a globe, made by Gemma Frisius and Gerhard Mercator (1537), showing a Fretum trium fratrum.
A second argument against the trip has been Columbus' observation of strong tidal movements. Greenland continued in the 15th century the trading with "Vineland", which had, according to bills, delivered products like Elk, black bear, ermine, glutton lynx, otter, sable and wolf (animals which were hunted in Newfoundland or Canada). (ed.), 1984 Dokumente zur Geschichte der europäischen Expansion, vol.
Was Christopher Columbus in Greenland 15 years before he discovered America?
Abstract Christopher Columbus wrote that he sailed in February 1477 to an island a hundred miles beyond Tile (Iceland).
This trip, which would have led him to Greenland according to the distance he mentioned, was questioned many times in the 20th century.
Arguments against accepting his claim have been that ice and snow would not have allowed him to make an expedition to the North in winter, and that the details he had given about the size of the tides (26 braccia) were far too overstated to be taken seriously.
First of all, one has to be aware, that in the 15th century it was generally very difficult to determine a ship's exact position.
To measure latitude Columbus still used the Quadrant: a quarter circle cut from wood or brass. In addition, Alexander Humboldt – himself an experienced explorer – pointed out that the diffuse sunlight in the North, especially in winter, made it very difficult to obtain precise readings. But it isn't just the possibility of a wrong measurement leading to the questionable statement of latitude.
And to this island, which is as big as England, the English, especially those from Bristol, go with their wares.
When I was there, the sea was not frozen, although there were very big tides, which in some places rose and fell twenty-six braccia (cubit). Unfortunately, the original document containing these words is lost.